← Corpus / augment-it / issue
A person's bio page on another org's site is an affiliation signal, not just an identity link — the UI should offer the promotion
A bio on another org's domain is three facts — identity link, affiliation evidence, observation. The card captures one and drops two.
- Path
- issues/Person-Bio-Pages-Are-Affiliation-Signals-Not-Just-Identity-Links.md
- Authors
- Michael Staton
- Augmented with
- Claude Code on Claude Fable 5
- Tags
- Issue · Usability · Augment-It · Affiliations · Persons · Identity-Links · Org-Workbench
Person bio pages are affiliation signals
The rule of thumb the operator already uses
If it’s static, it goes in identity. Profiles, bios, involvement pages
→ personal_links[]. That instinct is right and stays.
What gets dropped today
A bio hosted on someone else’s org domain carries more than identity.
The live case: Jamie Merisotis (Lumina Foundation card) has links to
linkedin, luminafoundation.org, forbes.com, bipartisanpolicy.org, and
wikipedia — every non-linkedin one badged other. The bipartisanpolicy.org
link is really:
- an identity link (captured ✓)
- evidence of an affiliation with the Bipartisan Policy Center — an organization worth its own record, which may not exist yet (dropped ✗)
- an observation —
affiliated_with, source: that URL (dropped ✗)
The schema handles all three today (person.affiliate is N-per-person and
match-or-CREATES the org; observations ride along automatically). Only the
UI path is missing: from a person’s link row, there’s no “this is also an
affiliation” affordance.
Direction (jotted)
- A “promote to affiliation” action on person link rows — takes the
link’s domain as the org seed → org match-or-create (the
AddPersonInlinegate pattern, inverted: person is fixed, org is being resolved) →person.affiliatewith optional role → observation cites the bio URL as source. Three clicks, no retyping. - Composes with the existing candidate machinery:
resolver.searchby domain (D4 already matchesdomains[*].domain) makes the org suggestion nearly free. - Same promotion logic belongs in the search-and-add rail eventually — a result row that IS a bio page could offer add-link and promote-to-affiliation.
- Sibling fact: those
otherbadges showinferLinkKindneeds richer vocabulary (org-bio / press-profile / wikipedia), or the same editable-kind treatment as [[Pulse-Streams-Need-Editable-Kind-And-User-Facing-Names]].
Open questions
- Where does the affordance live — a per-row action on the person card’s link list, a didi-chat verb, or both?
- When the org doesn’t exist: create thin (name + domain from the bio page) or route through a full org-resolution gate first?
- Should the observation’s free-text predicate distinguish
has_bio_atfromaffiliated_with, letting the human upgrade later?